Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 78 of 80
Phenol reacts with bromine in CS₂ at low temperature to give mainly 4-bromophenol, but with bromine water it gives a…
Question 782 marksHard
Phenol reacts with bromine in CS2 at low temperature to give mainly 4-bromophenol, but with bromine water it gives a white precipitate of 2,4,6-tribromophenol.
(a) Explain why the reaction stops at one bromine in CS2 but goes on to three in water. [1]
(b) 4-Nitrophenol is shaken with excess bromine water. Explain why only two bromine atoms enter the ring and name the product, and state whether it reacts faster or slower than phenol, giving a reason. Write the balanced equation. [1]
(a) The –OH group is so strongly activating (+R) that phenol can polarise a Br2 molecule without any Lewis acid (NCERT). The solvent then decides how far the reaction goes.
In CS2 at low temperature:CS2 has low polarity. It does not help to polarise Br–Br, it cannot stabilise the charged intermediate, and phenol does not ionise in it. With the low temperature as well, the reaction is slow and controlled, and it stops after one substitution. Para attack is preferred because the ortho positions are crowded by the adjacent –OH.
C6H5OH+Br2CS2,273Kp-BrC6H4OH+HBr
In water: water is highly polar. It strongly polarises the Br–Br bond and stabilises the charged intermediate, so the electrophile attacks much faster. Water also lets some phenol ionise to the phenoxide ion, whose full negative charge makes the ring even more reactive. The phenoxide is only a tiny fraction, but it is replaced as fast as it reacts. Every free ortho and para position is substituted rapidly, and the insoluble product precipitates.
C6H5OH+3Br2H2OC6H2Br3OH↓+3HBr
(b) Number the ring with –OH at C-1 and –NO2 at C-4.
Why only two Br. The –OH group directs to its ortho (C-2, C-6) and para (C-4) positions. C-4 is already occupied by –NO2, and the C–N bond is not broken in this substitution, so the para position is blocked. Only the two ortho positions are left. C-3 and C-5 are meta to –OH (and ortho to the electron-withdrawing –NO2), so they are not attacked. Excess bromine water therefore puts bromine at C-2 and C-6 only, and the product is 2,6-dibromo-4-nitrophenol:
O2NC6H4OH+2Br2H2OO2NC6H2Br2OH+2HBr
Atom check: C 6 = 6; H 5 = 3 + 2; N 1 = 1; O 3 = 3; Br 4 = 2 + 2.
Slower than phenol. –NO2 is strongly electron-withdrawing (–I and –R). It pulls electron density out of the ring, including from C-2 and C-6, so the ring is less able to attack the electrophile. 4-Nitrophenol does ionise more than phenol in water (pKa 7.1 against 10.0), but in its phenoxide ion the negative charge is delocalised onto the –NO2 oxygens instead of staying on the ring carbons. The –OH group still activates the ring enough for bromine water to react without a catalyst, but more slowly than with phenol.