Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 38 of 80
Methylenecyclohexane, C₆H₁0 =CH₂ , has its C=C double bond outside the ring, between a ring carbon and a CH₂ group.
Question 382 marksMedium
Methylenecyclohexane, C6H10=CH2, has its C=C double bond outside the ring, between a ring carbon and a CH2 group. It is converted into an alcohol by two different methods:
Method I: water in the presence of dilute sulphuric acid
Method II: diborane, followed by hydrogen peroxide in aqueous sodium hydroxide
Name the alcohol formed by each method and classify it as primary, secondary or tertiary. Explain why Method I can never give the alcohol formed in Method II.
In methylenecyclohexane the ring carbon of the double bond carries no hydrogen (it holds two ring bonds), while the outer CH2 carbon carries two hydrogens.
Method I: acid-catalysed hydration (Markovnikov).H+ adds to the outer CH2, so the positive charge sits on the ring carbon, giving a tertiary carbocation (three alkyl groups on it). Water attacks it and a proton is lost:
C6H10=CH2+H2OH+C6H10(CH3)OH
Product: 1-methylcyclohexan-1-ol, a tertiary alcohol.
Method II: hydroboration–oxidation. NCERT: boron attaches to the sp2 carbon carrying the greater number of hydrogen atoms, here the outer CH2, and oxidation puts −OH where the boron was:
Product: cyclohexylmethanol, a primary alcohol. The overall result looks like addition of water opposite to Markovnikov's rule.
Why Method I cannot give cyclohexylmethanol. To put −OH on the CH2 carbon, Method I would have to form the carbocation on that carbon, which would be a primary carbocation. Protonation always takes the path to the far more stable tertiary carbocation, so acid hydration gives only the 3∘ alcohol; hydroboration does not go through a carbocation at all.