Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 76 of 80
1-Methylcyclohexanol and 2-methylcyclohexanol are heated separately with an acid catalyst.
Question 762 marksHard
1-Methylcyclohexanol and 2-methylcyclohexanol are heated separately with an acid catalyst. Both give the same major alkene, but 1-methylcyclohexanol reacts under much milder conditions.
(a) Identify the major alkene and explain, using the carbocation each alcohol forms, why both alcohols give it. [1]
(b) Explain why 1-methylcyclohexanol dehydrates under milder conditions. [1]
(a)Major alkene: 1-methylcyclohexene.
1-Methylcyclohexanol loses water after protonation to give a tertiary carbocation at C-1 (the carbon bearing CH3). A proton is lost from a neighbouring ring CH2, giving the ring double bond C1=C2. This alkene has three alkyl groups on the double bond, so it is favoured over methylenecyclohexane (exocyclic C=CH2, only two alkyl groups).
2-Methylcyclohexanol gives a secondary carbocation at C-1 (the carbon that carried –OH). A proton can be lost from C-6 (giving 3-methylcyclohexene) or from C-2, which carries the methyl group (giving 1-methylcyclohexene). By Saytzeff's rule, the more substituted alkene forms mainly, so the major product is again 1-methylcyclohexene. The secondary cation can also undergo a 1,2-hydride shift from C-2, giving the same tertiary cation as 1-methylcyclohexanol, which again loses a proton to give 1-methylcyclohexene.
(b) In acid-catalysed dehydration, the rate-determining step is the formation of the carbocation (step 2 of NCERT's mechanism). 1-Methylcyclohexanol forms a tertiary carbocation, which is stabilised by three alkyl groups (+I effect and hyperconjugation). 2-Methylcyclohexanol must form the less stable secondary carbocation. The more stable the carbocation, the lower the activation energy of the slow step, so the tertiary alcohol dehydrates faster and at lower temperature and acid strength. This matches NCERT's order for ease of dehydration: tertiary > secondary > primary.