Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 68 of 80
In Kolbe's reaction, sodium phenoxide reacts with carbon dioxide (about 400 K, 4–7 atm), and acidification then gives…
Question 682 marksHard
In Kolbe's reaction, sodium phenoxide reacts with carbon dioxide (about 400 K, 4–7 atm), and acidification then gives 2-hydroxybenzoic acid (salicylic acid). Under the same conditions, phenol itself does not react with CO2.
(a) Using resonance structures, explain why the phenoxide ion reacts with CO2, a weak electrophile, while phenol does not. [1]
(b) Anisole is also activated towards electrophiles. Predict, with a reason, whether anisole gives a Kolbe product when heated with NaOH and CO2 under the same conditions. [1]
(a) In the phenoxide ion the oxygen already carries a full negative charge. Delocalising this charge into the ring puts a negative charge on the ortho and para carbons without creating any positive charge, so these structures contribute strongly and the ortho/para carbons become very electron rich.
In phenol, the ring can gain electron density only through structures with charge separation (O+ and C−). These structures are less stable and contribute less. The ring is activated, but not enough to attack a weak electrophile like CO2.
C6H5OH+NaOH→C6H5ONa+H2O
C6H5ONa+CO2400 K, 4–7 atmo-HOC6H4COONa
o-HOC6H4COONa+HCl→o-HOC6H4COOH+NaCl
(b)No. Anisole has no O–H hydrogen, so NaOH cannot convert it into an anion. Its ring is activated only through charge-separated structures (O+ and C−), exactly like neutral phenol. That is enough for strong electrophiles such as Br2 or NO2+, but not for the weak electrophile CO2. The negative charge created by deprotonation is the key feature of Kolbe's reaction, and anisole cannot provide it.