Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 65 of 80
When ethanol is heated with concentrated H₂SO₄ , the same protonated ethanol, CH₃CH₂– + O H₂ , forms first at every…
Question 652 marksHard
When ethanol is heated with concentrated H2SO4, the same protonated ethanol, CH3CH2–O+H2, forms first at every temperature. Yet the main product is ethoxyethane at 413 K and ethene at 443 K.
(a) Using the mechanism of each pathway, explain why the lower temperature favours the ether and the higher temperature favours the alkene. [1]
(b) To make ethoxyethane in good yield, ethanol is added continuously so that it is always in excess. Explain from the mechanism why an excess of ethanol favours the ether over the alkene. [1]
(a) Protonation turns –OH into a good leaving group (H2O). After that, the two pathways differ in how the C–O bond breaks.
Ether (413 K), SN2. A second ethanol molecule uses an oxygen lone pair to attack the CH2 carbon of protonated ethanol from the back. The new C–O bond forms at the same time as water leaves, so no free carbocation is needed. The energy released by forming the new bond pays for part of the bond breaking, so the activation energy is low and this path is fast even at 413 K. A proton is then lost from the protonated ether.
Alkene (443 K), via carbocation. Water must leave on its own, giving the unstable primary ethyl carbocation (NCERT: this is the slowest, rate-determining step). A C–H proton on the neighbouring carbon is then lost. Forming such an unstable carbocation needs a high activation energy, which becomes available only at the higher temperature.
CH3CH2OHconc. H2SO4443 KCH2=CH2+H2O
(b) In the ether path, the rate-determining step needs two species to meet: protonated ethanol and a molecule of free ethanol (a bimolecular step). Its rate therefore grows with the concentration of free ethanol. The alkene path starts from protonated ethanol alone, and free ethanol does not speed it up. Keeping ethanol in excess, and the temperature low, makes the bimolecular attack the fastest way for protonated ethanol to react, so the ether predominates. With too little ethanol and too much heat, the protonated ethanol loses water by itself and ethene forms instead.