Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 2 of 80
An ether X has the molecular formula C₄H₁0 O .
Question 21 markMCQMedium
An ether X has the molecular formula C4H10O. When X is heated with one mole of concentrated HI, the products are iodomethane and an alcohol Y. Y is separated and shaken with Lucas reagent (conc. HCl + anhydrous ZnCl2) at room temperature; the solution turns turbid only after about five minutes.
What is X?
Select your answer
(A) 1-methoxypropane
(B) ethoxyethane
(C) 2-methoxypropane
Correct answer
(D) butan-2-ol
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1: which ethers give iodomethane? When a mixed ether with primary or secondary alkyl groups is heated with HI, the ether is first protonated and then I− attacks the less substituted carbon by SN2. So the smaller alkyl group becomes the alkyl iodide. Iodomethane is formed only if X has a methyl group on oxygen. The C4H10O methyl ethers are 1-methoxypropane and 2-methoxypropane.
Step 2: use the Lucas test on Y.
1-Methoxypropane would give propan-1-ol, a 1∘ alcohol, which gives no turbidity at room temperature.
2-Methoxypropane gives propan-2-ol, a 2∘ alcohol, which turns turbid after a few minutes.
So X is 2-methoxypropane:
CH3OCH(CH3)2+HIΔCH3I+(CH3)2CHOH
Why the other options are wrong:
(A) gives iodomethane but its alcohol, propan-1-ol, is primary and would not turn turbid at room temperature.
(B) Ethoxyethane has no methyl group on oxygen, so it gives iodoethane and ethanol, not iodomethane.
(D) Butan-2-ol has the formula C4H10O but it is an alcohol, not an ether. With HI it gives 2-iodobutane and water, not iodomethane.