Data for the two hexaaquairon ions:
| Ion | d electrons | / cm⁻¹ | P / cm⁻¹ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 400 | 17 600 | ||
| 13 700 | 30 000 |
Which statement is correct?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 80 of 80
Data for the two hexaaquairon ions:
| Ion | d electrons | / cm⁻¹ | P / cm⁻¹ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 400 | 17 600 | ||
| 13 700 | 30 000 |
Which statement is correct?
(A) The ion has the larger , so it is closer to switching to low spin than the ion
(B) Both are high spin; BM for the ion and 5.92 BM for the ion
(C) Both are high spin ( BM for , 5.92 BM for ); the higher charge of raises , yet it is further from low spin because its pairing energy is much larger
(D) The ion is low spin, because increases with the charge on the metal ion; BM
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1: spin states. For both and , low spin needs .
Step 2: why is larger for . NCERT states that depends on the ligand field and on the charge of the metal ion. With the same ligand, the +3 ion pulls the water molecules closer and splits the d orbitals more.
Step 3: distance from the switch. What matters is how far falls short of P:
The half-filled ion has a very large pairing energy, so it is further from low spin even though its is larger.

Why the other options are wrong: