Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 44 of 80

Before X-ray methods existed, Werner used the number of isomers to decide the shape of six-coordinate complexes.

Question 441 markMCQHard

Before X-ray methods existed, Werner used the number of isomers to decide the shape of six-coordinate complexes. He considered three possible arrangements of six ligands around a metal: a regular hexagon (planar), a trigonal prism and an octahedron. For complexes of the types [MA4B2][\text{MA}_4\text{B}_2] (e.g. CoCl3⋅4NH3\text{CoCl}_3\cdot 4\text{NH}_3, which exists in a green and a violet form) and [MA3B3][\text{MA}_3\text{B}_3] (e.g. [Co(NH3)3(NO2)3][\text{Co(NH}_3)_3(\text{NO}_2)_3]), he never found more than two isomers.

Which statement correctly explains his conclusion?

Select your answer
  • (A) The hexagonal planar and trigonal prismatic shapes each predict three geometrical isomers for [MA4B2][\text{MA}_4\text{B}_2] and three for [MA3B3][\text{MA}_3\text{B}_3], while the octahedron predicts two for each; so only the octahedron fits the observations.

    Correct answer
  • (B) The hexagonal planar shape predicts only two isomers (cis and trans) for [MA4B2][\text{MA}_4\text{B}_2], so it can be ruled out only by the [MA3B3][\text{MA}_3\text{B}_3] data.

  • (C) The trigonal prism predicts two isomers for [MA3B3][\text{MA}_3\text{B}_3] and three for [MA4B2][\text{MA}_4\text{B}_2], so the green and violet forms of CoCl3⋅4NH3\text{CoCl}_3\cdot 4\text{NH}_3 alone rule it out.

  • (D) The octahedron predicts three isomers for [MA3B3][\text{MA}_3\text{B}_3] (fac, mer and one more), which is why Werner looked for, and failed to find, the third one.