Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 78 of 80
A student claims: "Measure the magnetic moment of an octahedral complex and you can always tell whether its ligand is…
Question 783 marksMedium
A student claims: "Measure the magnetic moment of an octahedral complex and you can always tell whether its ligand is a strong-field or a weak-field ligand."
(a) For octahedral d1 to d10 ions, show in a table the number of unpaired electrons in a weak field (Δo<P) and in a strong field (Δo>P).
(b) For which d-electron counts can the magnetic moment reveal the strength of the ligand field?
(c)[Ni(H2O)6]2+ and [Ni(NH3)6]2+ both have μ=2.83 BM. Does this show that H2O and NH3 produce equal crystal field splittings? Explain, and state how the difference between the two ligands can be detected instead.
(a) Unpaired electrons
The t2g set fills first. For d1–d3 each electron goes singly into t2g (Hund's rule). The choice arises only when a fourth electron must either pair in t2g (cost P) or go up to eg (cost Δo).
dn
Weak field
n
Strong field
n
d1
t2g1
1
t2g1
1
d2
t2g2
2
t2g2
2
d3
t2g3
3
t2g3
3
d4
t2g3eg1
4
t2g4
2
d5
t2g3eg2
5
t2g5
1
d6
t2g4eg2
4
t2g6
0
d7
t2g5eg2
3
t2g6eg1
1
d8
t2g6eg2
2
t2g6eg2
2
d9
t2g6eg3
1
t2g6eg3
1
d10
t2g6eg4
0
t2g6eg4
0
(b) When magnetism can decide
Only for d4, d5, d6 and d7 do the two columns differ. For these ions the moment shows whether Δo>P (strong field) or Δo<P (weak field). For d1–d3 and d8–d10 there is only one possible arrangement, so the student's claim fails for these ions.
(c) The nickel(II) pair
Ni2+ is d8. Six electrons fill t2g and the remaining two must go into eg whatever the size of Δo. So both complexes have two unpaired electrons:
μ=2(2+2)=2.83BM
The equal moments say nothing about the splittings. In fact NH3 lies above H2O in the spectrochemical series, so [Ni(NH3)6]2+ has the larger Δo. The difference shows up in the absorption spectrum (colour): the ammine complex absorbs at a shorter wavelength (higher energy) than the green aqua complex.