(a) Fe(0) versus Fe(III)
The M–C bond has two parts:
- σ donation: the lone pair on carbon goes into an empty metal orbital. CO is a weak σ-donor, so this part alone gives only a weak bond.
- π back-donation: a filled metal d orbital gives electrons to the empty π∗ orbital of CO. This part provides most of the bond strength.
Fe(0) has 8 valence electrons (3d64s2) and no positive charge, so it holds its d electrons loosely and can back-donate strongly.
Fe3+ is 3d5 with a high positive charge. It holds its fewer d electrons tightly and back-donates very little. Only the weak σ donation would remain, which is not enough to hold six CO ligands.
So stable carbonyls are formed by metals in low oxidation states (zero, negative or at most low positive, such as Mn(+1) in [Mn(CO)6]+), which are electron-rich enough to back-donate.

(b) Why the two components reinforce each other
- σ donation adds electron density to the metal. This makes the metal more able to push electrons back into CO π∗, so σ donation strengthens back-donation.
- Back-donation removes the extra electron density from the metal, so the metal can accept further σ donation from carbon more easily. So back-donation strengthens σ donation.
Each flow of electrons supports the other, so the M–C bond is much stronger than either part alone could make it. This mutual strengthening is the synergic effect. It also weakens the C–O bond, because the back-donated electrons enter an orbital that is antibonding for C–O.