Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 46 of 80
X²+ and Y³+ are ions of two consecutive elements (atomic numbers differ by one) of the first transition series.
Question 461 markMCQHard
X2+ and Y3+ are ions of two consecutive elements (atomic numbers differ by one) of the first transition series. The two ions are isoelectronic, and each has a spin-only magnetic moment of 4.90 BM. The element X forms an oxide XO3, which dissolves in water to give an acidic solution.
When a solution of X2+ is mixed with a solution of Y3+, a redox reaction takes place at once. What are the spin-only magnetic moments of the X-containing ion and of the Y-containing ion formed in this reaction?
Select your answer
(A) 3.87 BM and 5.92 BM respectively
Correct answer
(B) 5.92 BM and 3.87 BM respectively
(C) 4.90 BM and 4.90 BM respectively
(D) 2.83 BM and 5.92 BM respectively
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1 — Which ions have 4.90 BM?
μ=n(n+2)=4.90⇒n(n+2)=24⇒n=4
Four unpaired electrons means 3d4 or 3d6. An isoelectronic pair X2+/Y3+ from consecutive elements must have the same d count, so there are two candidate pairs:
Pair
Configuration
X forms XO3?
Cr2+ / Mn3+
3d4
yes: CrO3 is acidic
Fe2+ / Co3+
3d6
no: iron has no oxide above Fe2O3
So X = Cr and Y = Mn.
Step 2 — The reaction. From NCERT Table 4.2, E∘(Cr3+/Cr2+)=−0.41 V and E∘(Mn3+/Mn2+)=+1.57 V. Mn3+ is a strong oxidant and Cr2+ a strong reductant:
Cr2++Mn3+→Cr3++Mn2+Ecell∘=1.57−(−0.41)=+1.98V
Step 3 — Moments of the products.
Cr3+(3d3,n=3):μ=15=3.87BM
Mn2+(3d5,n=5):μ=35=5.92BM
Why the others are wrong:
(B) This is what the Fe2+/Co3+ pair would give (Fe3+3d5 = 5.92 BM, Co2+3d7 = 3.87 BM). That pair is ruled out by the XO3 clue.
(C) It assumes no reaction. But each ion changes its d count by one, so neither moment can stay at 4.90 BM.
(D) 2.83 BM corresponds to two unpaired electrons (3d2). Cr3+ is 3d3: Cr (3d54s1) loses the 4s electron and two 3d electrons.