Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 44 of 80
An unknown salt contains the aquated ion M²+ of a first-row transition metal. Three observations are made
Question 441 markMCQHard
An unknown salt contains the aquated ion M2+ of a first-row transition metal. Three observations are made:
(i) The spin-only magnetic moment calculated for M2+ is 3.87 BM (the measured value is somewhat higher).
(ii) The aqueous solution of M2+ is pink.
(iii) When M2+ is oxidised to M3+, the M3+ ion slowly oxidises water, liberating oxygen.
Which statement about M is correct?
Select your answer
(A) M is V, because V2+ also has three unpaired electrons; its M3+ ion is therefore a strong oxidising agent.
(B) M is Co; M2+ is oxidised rapidly by air in water, so its salts must be stored under nitrogen.
(C) M is Co; since E∘(M3+/M2+) is large and positive, M2+ is a strong reducing agent, like Cr2+.
(D) M is Co; the gaseous M3+ ion has a spin-only magnetic moment of 4.90 BM, and M2+, though stable in water, is easily oxidised to M3+ in the presence of complexing reagents.
Correct answer
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1 — Observation (i) leaves two candidates. 3.87 BM means three unpaired electrons:
μ=n(n+2)=3.87⇒n(n+2)=15⇒n=3
A 3d ion with three unpaired electrons is either 3d3 or 3d7. As M2+ ions these are V2+ (3d3) and Co2+ (3d7: two pairs and three single electrons).
Step 2 — Observations (ii) and (iii) decide. From NCERT Table 4.8, V2+(aq) is violet while Co2+(aq) is pink. Also E∘(Co3+/Co2+)=+1.97 V is greater than the +1.23 V needed to oxidise water, so Co3+ liberates oxygen:
4Co3++2H2O→4Co2++O2+4H+
(Check: O 2 = 2, H 4 = 4, charge +12=+8+4.) By contrast E∘(V3+/V2+)=−0.26 V, so V3+ is not an oxidant at all. So M = Co.
Step 3 — Check (D).Co3+ is [Ar]3d6; the free (gaseous) ion has four unpaired electrons:
μ=4×6=24=4.90BM
NCERT (Exercise 4.21) notes that cobalt(II) is stable in aqueous solution but is easily oxidised in the presence of complexing reagents. Both parts of (D) are correct.
Why the others are wrong:
(A) V fits observation (i) only. V2+ is violet, not pink, and E∘(V3+/V2+) is negative, so V3+ cannot oxidise water.
(B) It is the reverse of the truth: Co2+ is the stable state of cobalt in water. The very high E∘ means Co3+ is hard to reach, not easy.
(C) A large positive E∘(M3+/M2+) makes M3+ a strong oxidant and M2+ a very weak reductant. Cr2+ is a strong reductant for the opposite reason: E∘(Cr3+/Cr2+)=−0.41 V.