Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 66 of 80
An unlabelled bottle contains a pale solution of a sulphate of a 3d metal.
Question 662 marksMedium
An unlabelled bottle contains a pale solution of a sulphate of a 3d metal. The metal ion has a spin-only magnetic moment of 5.92 BM. It could be either Mn2+ or Fe3+.
(a) Show why the magnetic moment alone cannot tell the two ions apart.
(b) Using the E∘ values, propose a test with KI solution that distinguishes them. Write the balanced ionic equation for the ion that reacts, and state how the magnetic moment of the metal ion changes after the reaction.
(a) Why the moment cannot decide
μ=n(n+2)=5.92BM⇒n(n+2)=35⇒n=5
Both candidates have five unpaired electrons:
Mn2+: Mn is 3d54s2; losing the two 4s electrons leaves 3d5.
Fe3+: Fe is 3d64s2; losing two 4s electrons and one 3d electron leaves 3d5.
Magnetism counts unpaired electrons, not the element, so two ions with the same d5 count give the same moment.
(b) The KI test
Add KI solution (with a little starch):
Fe3+ reacts.Ecell∘=0.77−0.54=+0.23V, so Fe3+ oxidises iodide. Brown iodine appears (blue-black with starch).
2Fe3++2I−→2Fe2++I2
Mn2+ does not react.Mn2+ is the reduced form of the Mn3+/Mn2+ couple. To oxidise iodide it would itself have to be reduced below +2, which does not happen. Iodide is a reducing agent, and Mn2+ (3d5) strongly resists oxidation.
Magnetic check: after the reaction, iron is present as Fe2+ (3d6, 4 unpaired):
μ=4×6=4.90BM
The moment falls from 5.92 BM to 4.90 BM only if the ion was Fe3+. A Mn2+ solution still reads 5.92 BM.