Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
For a cycle, both steps must be feasible (positive Ecell∘):
- Step A (higher state oxidises H2O2 to O2) needs E∘(Mn+1/Mn)>+0.68 V.
- Step B (lower state reduces H2O2 to H2O) needs E∘(Mn+1/Mn)<+1.78 V.
So the couple must lie in the window +0.68 V to +1.78 V.
| Couple | E∘ (V) | Step A (>0.68)? | Step B (<1.78)? | Catalyst? |
|---|
| Co3+/Co2+ | +1.97 | yes | no | no |
| Fe3+/Fe2+ | +0.77 | yes | yes | yes |
| Cu2+/Cu+ | +0.15 | no | yes | no |
| Cr3+/Cr2+ | −0.41 | no | yes | no |

The iron cycle:
2Fe3++H2O2→2Fe2++O2+2H+Ecell∘=0.77−0.68=+0.09 V
2Fe2++H2O2+2H+→2Fe3++2H2OEcell∘=1.78−0.77=+1.01 V
Checks: charge +6=+4+2 and +4+2=+6; O and H balance in both. Adding them gives 2H2O2→2H2O+O2, with iron regenerated.
Why the others are wrong:
- (A) and (C) Co3+ oxidises H2O2 easily, but the Co2+ produced cannot be re-oxidised by H2O2 (1.78−1.97=−0.19 V). The cycle stops after one turn, so cobalt is used up, not a catalyst.
- (D) Cr2+ and Cu+ reduce H2O2 readily, but Cr3+ and Cu2+ cannot oxidise H2O2 to O2 (negative Ecell∘). Again the cycle cannot close.
The same rule explains the NCERT example, where 0.77 V lies between 0.54 V (I2/I−) and 2.01 V (S2O82−/SO42−): a good redox catalyst has an E∘ between those of the two couples it links.