(i) Going round the rings:
| Carbon | Z | W |
|---|
| C1 | −OH up | −OH up |
| C2 | −OH down | −OH down |
| C3 | −OH up | −OH up |
| C4 | −OH down | −OH up |
| C5 | −CH2OH up | −CH2OH up |
Z and W differ only at C4. Z is β-D-glucopyranose (β-D-glucose) and W is β-D-galactopyranose (β-D-galactose), the two units of lactose.
The student is wrong. Anomers are the two cyclic forms of the same sugar that differ only in the configuration at C1, the anomeric carbon (as α-D-glucose and β-D-glucose do). In Z and W the C1 −OH is on the same side (up, so both are β-forms); the difference lies at C4. Z and W are therefore two different sugars, which is why lactose gives two different monosaccharides on hydrolysis.

(ii) No. When Z changes into its other cyclic form, only the ring bond at the anomeric carbon is involved: the ring C1–O bond breaks, giving the open-chain form with a free −CHO group at C1, and the C5–OH adds to the −CHO again from the other side. Only the configuration at C1 can change; no bond to C2, C3, C4 or C5 is broken. W treated in the same way gives only the other cyclic form of D-galactose. The −OH at C4 of W keeps its position, so W can never become Z.
Both are D-sugars because of C5, the lowest asymmetric carbon of the open chain (the one farthest from the carbonyl carbon). In the open chain its −OH is on the right, as in D-glyceraldehyde, and in the Haworth ring this shows up as the −CH2OH group on C5 pointing up, in both Z and W.