A materials scientist studies four binary liquid mixtures for industrial cleaning. She records:
| Mixture | Vapour pressure compared with Raoult's law | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| W | equal | ||
| X | lower | ||
| Y | higher | ||
| Z | lower |
(a) Identify which mixture is ideal and which shows negative deviation from Raoult's law. Justify.
(b) For mixture Y, describe the A–B interactions compared with A–A and B–B, and explain the sign of .
(c) Are the three properties recorded for Z consistent with one another, in terms of the model of solutions used in NCERT? Which entry looks out of place, and what would you do about it?

