Two water samples have exactly the same BOD. One is raw sewage diluted with river water; the other is river water polluted by waste from a sugar factory. Which statement is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 29 of 80
Two water samples have exactly the same BOD.
(A) Both samples must contain the same pathogens.
(B) Both samples must come from the same source.
- Correct answer
(C) The two samples have about the same amount of organic matter, as indirectly measured by BOD, but the BOD does not tell us what that matter is or whether pathogens are present.
(D) A BOD value tells us the exact chemical composition of the water.
Option (C) is correct.
Concept — what BOD measures. BOD is the amount of oxygen that would be consumed if all the organic matter in one litre of water were oxidised by bacteria. NCERT: "The BOD test measures the rate of uptake of oxygen by micro-organisms in a sample of water and thus, indirectly, BOD is a measure of the organic matter present in the water."
Step 1 — What equal BOD tells us. The two samples use up oxygen at about the same rate, so they contain about the same amount of oxidisable organic matter. The reading is indirect, so this is an estimate of quantity only.
Step 2 — What BOD does not tell us. A single BOD number says nothing about what kind of organic matter is present, where it came from, or whether the water carries pathogens. The sewage sample is likely to contain the pathogens of human excreta; the sugar-factory sample need not.
Answer: (C) — about the same amount of organic matter, but BOD does not reveal its nature or the presence of pathogens.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) BOD measures oxygen uptake, not pathogens; the sugar-factory waste need not carry the pathogens found in sewage.
- (B) The question itself gives two different sources with the same BOD, so equal BOD cannot mean the same source.
- (D) BOD is only an indirect measure of the amount of organic matter; it gives no chemical composition.
