A research team collects samples from four places: water from a thermal vent at about 100 °C, soil from under several metres of snow, water from a highly acidic lake, and air from a hospital ward. In which of these would they expect to find living microbes?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 1 of 80
A research team collects samples from four places: water from a thermal vent at about 100 °C, soil from under several…
(A) Only in the hospital air
(B) Only in the thermal vent and the acidic lake
(C) In the snow, the acidic lake and the hospital air, but not at 100 °C
- Correct answer
(D) In all four places
Option (D) is correct.
Concept — microbes are present everywhere. NCERT: microbes are present "in soil, water, air, inside our bodies and that of other animals and plants". They are found "even at sites where no other life-form could possibly exist – sites such as deep inside the geysers (thermal vents) where the temperature may be as high as 100 °C, deep in the soil, under the layers of snow several metres thick, and in highly acidic environments."
Step 1 — Check each sample against NCERT.
- Thermal vent at about 100 °C: named by NCERT (geysers) — microbes present.
- Soil under several metres of snow: named by NCERT — microbes present.
- Highly acidic lake: named by NCERT (highly acidic environments) — microbes present.
- Hospital air: microbes are present in air — microbes present.
Step 2 — Conclude. All four samples are expected to contain living microbes.
Answer: (D) in all four places.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) It leaves out the thermal vent, the snow-covered soil and the acidic lake, all of which NCERT names as places where microbes live.
- (B) It leaves out the snow-covered soil and the hospital air.
- (C) It wrongly excludes the thermal vent: NCERT says microbes live in geysers where the temperature may be as high as 100 °C.
