Two 10-year-old cousins are exposed to the same pollen. Riya grew up in a metro city, in a very clean, protected home. Arun grew up on a farm. Riya develops sneezing and wheezing; Arun does not. Which explanation fits NCERT's view?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 28 of 80
Two 10-year-old cousins are exposed to the same pollen.
(A) Arun's body cannot make IgE antibodies at all.
- Correct answer
(B) A protected environment early in life may lower immunity and increase sensitivity to allergens, so Riya over-reacts.
(C) Riya has an infection, since allergy happens only to germs.
(D) Pollen reaches only the lungs of city children.
Option (B) is correct.
Concept used — allergy, and NCERT's "protected environment" explanation
Allergy is the exaggerated response of the immune system to certain antigens present in the environment, called allergens (for example pollen and mites in dust). The antibodies produced are of the IgE type, and chemicals such as histamine and serotonin released from mast cells cause the symptoms. NCERT adds: "Somehow, modern-day life style has resulted in lowering of immunity and more sensitivity to allergens – more and more children in metro cities of India suffer from allergies and asthma due to sensitivity to the environment. This could be because of the protected environment provided early in life."
Step 1 — Find the one difference between the cousins. Both are 10 years old and both met the same pollen. The only difference given is the upbringing: Riya in a very clean, protected metro home; Arun on a farm.
Step 2 — Apply NCERT to Riya. She is exactly the metro child, raised in a protected environment, whom NCERT describes as more sensitive to allergens. Her immune system over-reacts to harmless pollen, giving sneezing and wheezing.
Step 3 — Explain Arun. Pollen is a harmless antigen. Arun's immune system meets it without an exaggerated response, so he has no symptoms.
Answer: option (B): a protected environment early in life may lower immunity and increase sensitivity to allergens, so Riya over-reacts.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) Nothing suggests that Arun cannot make IgE. Having no symptoms means his response to this pollen is not exaggerated, not that he lacks the antibody.
- (C) Allergy is a response to harmless environmental antigens such as pollen and dust mites, not to germs; Riya has no infection.
- (D) Both children breathed the same pollen, and pollen does not choose city lungs. The difference lies in how each immune system responds, not in where the pollen goes.
