(a) Person A had been vaccinated. The evidence:
- A's antibody level starts rising within about 3 days, while B's rises only after about 10 days.
- A's peak is several times higher than B's.
A shows a secondary (anamnestic) response; B shows a primary response.
(b) The vaccine exposed A to the antigen earlier. The resulting primary response produced memory B- and T-cells. When the same virus arrived, these memory cells recognised it and responded rapidly and intensely. B has no memory cells, so his B- and T-cells must meet the antigen for the first time, which is a slow, low-intensity response.
(c) Person B. His antibodies barely reach the level needed for protection, and only after about two weeks. Meanwhile the virus can multiply and cause disease. A's antibodies pass the protective level within about 4 days and stay far above it.