A healthy nurse who had never met a new pathogen was given plasma from patients who had recovered from it, before she began work in the isolation ward. She stayed well for some weeks. Six months later she caught the disease and was as ill as anyone who had never been protected. Which statement explains both observations?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 41 of 80
A healthy nurse who had never met a new pathogen was given plasma from patients who had recovered from it, before she…
(A) The plasma contained the antigen, so it gave her active immunity, which faded after six months.
- Correct answer
(B) The plasma supplied ready-made antibodies (passive immunity), which protected her at once but produced no memory cells.
(C) The plasma contained memory cells from the donors, which protected her until they died out.
(D) The pathogen changed completely within six months, so her memory cells no longer recognised it.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: The plasma of recovered patients contains preformed antibodies. Transferring them gives passive immunity: the protection is immediate, which is why she stayed well at first. However, these antibodies were made by other people's B-cells, not by her own, so no memory cells of her own were formed. The transferred antibodies were gradually removed from her body. When she met the pathogen six months later, she had to mount a slow primary response from scratch.
- (A) Plasma from recovered patients supplies antibodies, not the antigen; and active immunity would have left memory, giving her a fast secondary response.
- (C) Plasma is the fluid part of the blood; it carries antibodies, not memory cells.
- (D) Nothing in the case suggests this. The simpler explanation is that she never had memory cells.
