Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 80 of 80

Case: A student writes: "Pasteur proved that life comes only from pre-existing life.

Question 805 marksHard

Case: A student writes: "Pasteur proved that life comes only from pre-existing life. Yet NCERT says the majority accept that the first form of life arose slowly from non-living molecules. So NCERT is contradicting itself."

(a) Pasteur's flasks held killed yeast for a short time under present-day conditions. State two ways in which the conditions NCERT describes for the origin of life on the early earth were different.

(b) Explain why the two statements quoted by the student do not contradict each other.

(c) NCERT says that Pasteur's work "did not answer how the first life form came on earth". Why could an experiment of this kind never answer that question?

(d) In NCERT's account, the first non-cellular forms of life were giant molecules (RNA, protein, polysaccharides) that "reproduced their molecules perhaps". Why is this ability to reproduce the step that separates them from the amino acids formed in Miller's flask?