A farmer breeds only from the cows that give the most milk, and over many generations the herd's milk yield rises.
How does this differ from natural selection?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 3 of 80
A farmer breeds only from the cows that give the most milk, and over many generations the herd's milk yield rises.
How does this differ from natural selection?
(A) Here humans, not the natural environment, decide which heritable variants reproduce; the principle of selecting inherited variation is the same.
(B) Here the cows acquire higher yield by being milked more, and pass it on.
(C) Here new genes for milk are created by the farmer's choice.
(D) There is no difference; artificial selection is a type of natural selection by nature.
Option (A) is correct.
Concept used — artificial selection compared with natural selection
In both kinds of selection, individuals with certain heritable variations leave more offspring, so those variations become commoner over generations. The only difference is who does the selecting.
Step 1 — Identify the selecting agent here. The farmer (man) chooses which cows breed, on the basis of milk yield. In natural selection the choice is made by the environment (climate, food, predators).
Step 2 — Identify what is common. In both cases the selected character must be inherited; selection only changes how often existing heritable variants appear in the next generation.
Step 3 — Link to NCERT. NCERT uses breeding as evidence: if man could create new breeds within hundreds of years, nature could have done the same over millions of years.
Answer: option (A) — humans, not the environment, decide which heritable variants reproduce.
Why the other options are wrong