Humans have created breeds of dogs that differ greatly from one another within a few hundred years. How does NCERT use this as evidence for evolution?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 26 of 80
Humans have created breeds of dogs that differ greatly from one another within a few hundred years.
(A) It proves that dogs evolved from humans.
(B) It shows that all breeds are separate species.
(C) It shows that acquired characters are inherited.
- Correct answer
(D) If man could create new breeds within hundreds of years, nature could have produced new forms over millions of years.
Option (D) is correct.
Concept used — artificial selection as evidence for evolution
Intensive breeding by man has produced breeds (for example, of dogs) that differ from one another but are still of the same group. NCERT argues: "if within hundreds of years, man could create new breeds, could not nature have done the same over millions of years?"
Step 1 — What breeding shows. Selecting heritable variation, generation after generation, can change a population's characters a great deal in a short time.
Step 2 — Extend it to nature. Nature selects too, and it has had millions of years, so it could produce new forms of life.
Answer: option (D).
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) Dogs did not evolve from humans; humans only bred the different breeds of dogs.
- (B) NCERT says the breeds differ from one another but are still of the same group, not separate species.
- (C) Inheritance of acquired characters is Lamarck's idea; breeding shows the power of selecting heritable variation, which is Darwin's point.
