The hearts of a fish, a frog and a human differ in the number of chambers and in how blood flows through them, but all are built on a common vertebrate plan. These hearts are best described as:
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 12 of 80
The hearts of a fish, a frog and a human differ in the number of chambers and in how blood flows through them, but all…
(A) analogous, because their structures differ
(B) vestigial, because some chambers are reduced
- Correct answer
(C) homologous, since they share a common basic plan that has been modified in different groups
(D) examples of convergent evolution, since they perform the same function
Option (C) is correct.
Concept used — homology and divergent evolution
Organs are homologous when they share the same basic structure and origin, inherited from a common ancestor, even if they have been modified in different directions for different needs. This is divergent evolution. Organs are analogous when they do the same function but are not anatomically similar and come from different ancestry (convergent evolution).
Step 1 — Apply it to the hearts. The hearts of fish, frog and human differ in the number of chambers and the path of blood, but all are built on the common vertebrate plan. That shared plan comes from a common ancestor.
Step 2 — Match with NCERT. NCERT names vertebrate hearts or brains as examples of homology.
Answer: option (C) — the hearts are homologous.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) Differences in detail do not make organs analogous. Analogy needs structures that are not anatomically similar, in groups that do not share that structure by descent; these hearts share one basic plan.
- (B) A vestigial organ is one that has lost its function. Every one of these hearts pumps blood fully; fewer chambers in the fish heart is a different design, not a reduced, useless remnant.
- (D) Convergent evolution produces similar function from different structures. Here the structures share a common plan, so the pattern is divergent, not convergent.
