Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Two areas on the same species-area line obey log S₂ − log S₁ = Z × (log A₂ − log A₁), that is, S₂ ÷ S₁ = (A₂ ÷ A₁)^Z. Here log 6 − log 14 = 0.778 − 1.146 = −0.368.
Assertion is false. The forests are compared across different continents. NCERT: for "very large areas like the entire continents" the slope is much steeper, "Z values in the range of 0.6 to 1.2" (1.15 for frugivorous birds and mammals in the tropical forests of different continents).
- Z = 0.6: 0.6 × (−0.368) = −0.221, and 10^−0.221 = 0.60
- Z = 1.2: 1.2 × (−0.368) = −0.442, and 10^−0.442 = 0.36
So the smaller area would be expected to hold only about 36 to 60 per cent as many species. No slope at this scale gives 88 per cent.
Reason is true. NCERT: the value of Z "lies in the range of 0.1 to 0.2, regardless of the taxonomic group or the region" (plants in Britain, birds in California, molluscs in New York state).
The 88 per cent in the Assertion comes from a within-region slope, Z = 0.15: 0.15 × (−0.368) = −0.055, and 10^−0.055 = 0.88. The Reason is true, but it describes the wrong scale for this comparison, so it cannot rescue the Assertion.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) treats the Assertion as true, but at the scale of continents the smaller area holds only about 36 to 60 per cent as many species.
- (B) also treats the Assertion as true; the 88 per cent figure needs a within-region slope that does not apply across continents.
- (C) rejects the Reason, which is NCERT's own statement about Z within a region.
