The real tropics differ from temperate regions in three ways at once. They have had more evolutionary time without glaciation, their climate is more constant, and they receive more solar energy. An ecologist wants to know which difference matters most, so she looks for pairs of regions of equal area that differ in only one factor. (Hypothetical pairs.)
| Pair | Region 1 | Region 2 |
|---|---|---|
| I | undisturbed for millions of years | glaciated repeatedly until recently |
| II | constant, predictable climate | strongly seasonal, unpredictable climate |
| III | high solar energy | low solar energy (persistent cloud) |
In each pair, everything else is the same.
(a) For each pair, name the hypothesis that predicts a difference in species richness, and state which region it predicts will be richer. Explain the reasoning. (3)
(b) Explain why a simple comparison of a tropical forest with a temperate forest cannot tell us which of the three hypotheses is right. (1)
(c) In pair III, the ecologist finds that both regions have the same productivity and the same species richness. Does this result disprove the solar-energy hypothesis? Explain. (1)
