Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 59 of 80

A conservation board can afford to protect only two of three species of a hill forest.

Question 593 marksHard

A conservation board can afford to protect only two of three species of a hill forest. (Hypothetical case.)

  • Species X: a shrub whose bark yields a dye sold to industry.
  • Species Y: a bat that is the main pollinator of the valley's fruit trees.
  • Species Z: a small cave beetle with no known use and no known role in the forest.

(a) One member proposes X and Y, "because we know what they are worth". Using the rivet popper hypothesis, explain why leaving Z out is a gamble. (1)

(b) Rank the three species for the two places. Justify your ranking, using both the rivet popper hypothesis and the ethical argument. (2)