A student wants to find out whether the chemical composition of litter or the climate of a site has the larger effect on decomposition. She has two kinds of litter and two sites with the same soil moisture:
- Litter X: 30 per cent lignin, 0.5 per cent nitrogen
- Litter Y: 8 per cent lignin, 2.5 per cent nitrogen
- Warm site: mean 26 °C
- Cold site: mean 5 °C
(a) Design the experiment. Describe the treatments, what must be kept the same, and what should be measured. (2)
(b) Using NCERT, predict which treatment will lose the most mass and which the least. Can NCERT tell you the order of the other two? (1)
(c) Her results, as percentage of dry mass lost in one year, are: X warm 40, Y warm 80, X cold 10, Y cold 30. (Hypothetical data.) Calculate the effect of litter type at each site and the effect of site for each litter. State a conclusion that the data support. (2)
