Plots of grassland at two sites received extra water, extra nutrients (fertiliser), both, or neither, for one year. All other conditions were the same within each site. The NPP of each plot was measured. (Hypothetical data.)
| Treatment | NPP at Site 1, high rainfall (g m⁻² yr⁻¹) | NPP at Site 2, low rainfall (g m⁻² yr⁻¹) |
|---|---|---|
| Neither (control) | 300 | 100 |
| Water only | 330 | 250 |
| Nutrients only | 600 | 110 |
| Water and nutrients | 640 | 400 |
(a) For Site 1, calculate the percentage increase in NPP caused by water alone and by nutrients alone. Which factor limited NPP most? (1)
(b) At Site 1, adding water to plots that already had nutrients raised NPP by only 40 g m⁻² yr⁻¹. What does this tell you, and what can the data not tell you? (1)
(c) For Site 2, compare the increase caused by water and nutrients together with the sum of the increases caused by each alone. Explain the result. (2)
(d) Use these results to explain NCERT's statement that primary productivity "varies in different types of ecosystems". (1)
