A student wants to test whether the bark-like colouring of a moth protects it from birds (camouflage). Which experimental design would test this most fairly?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 47 of 80
A student wants to test whether the bark-like colouring of a moth protects it from birds (camouflage).
(A) Count how many of these moths birds eat in a forest where the tree bark matches the moth, with nothing to compare against.
(B) Place live moths of two different species on the same bark, one bark-coloured and one brightly coloured, and count how many of each the birds eat.
(C) Place bark-coloured moths on bark in the morning and on white boards in the evening, and count how many are eaten each time.
- Correct answer
(D) Pin equal numbers of identical, edible moth models, half coloured like the bark and half in a contrasting colour, on the same tree trunks at the same time, and count how many of each the birds take.
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: NCERT: "Some species of insects and frogs are cryptically-coloured (camouflaged) to avoid being detected easily by the predator." To test this, only colour against the background may differ between the two groups. Everything else (taste, size, shape, place, time) must be the same, and there must be a comparison group.
Design (D) does this: the models are identical and equally edible, and they are on the same trunks at the same time. Any difference in the number taken can therefore be due only to how well they match the bark.
- (A) Has no comparison group, so we cannot tell whether colour makes any difference.
- (B) The two species may differ in other ways, such as taste. A distasteful or poisonous species is avoided for a different reason, so colour is not the only difference.
- (C) Changes the time of day as well as the background, so the effect of colour cannot be separated from differences in bird activity.
