A seed-eating bird species lives on two islands. On both islands the birds have either large beaks or small beaks, and each island starts with 500 of each. Island C also has a second, unrelated species that eats only small seeds; island D does not. The survival of the first species over one dry year is given in the table below. (Hypothetical data.)
| Beak type | Survival on D (no competitor) | Survival on C (competitor present) |
|---|---|---|
| Small | 60 per cent | 20 per cent |
| Large | 60 per cent | 55 per cent |
(a) Calculate the number of each beak type surviving on each island, and the percentage of large-beaked birds among the survivors.
(b) Explain how these results illustrate Darwin's view of interspecific competition.
(c) Predict what would happen to the beak types on island C over many generations if competition continued, and state what extra evidence you would need before making this prediction with confidence.
(d) Species facing competition might also evolve in ways that promote co-existence rather than exclusion. Suggest how the change you predicted in (c) could have that effect.
