Every batch of polio vaccine is tested for safety before it is used on humans. A laboratory tests 20 batches both in monkeys (the present method) and in transgenic mice. (Hypothetical data.)
| Result | Number of batches |
|---|---|
| Safe in monkeys, safe in mice | 16 |
| Unsafe in monkeys, unsafe in mice | 3 |
| Unsafe in monkeys, but safe in mice | 1 |
| Safe in monkeys, but unsafe in mice | 0 |
(a) In what percentage of batches did the two methods agree?
(b) Which type of disagreement is the more serious for public safety? Explain.
(c) NCERT says transgenic mice "could replace the use of monkeys to test the safety of batches of the vaccine" on one condition. State the condition, and decide whether this laboratory should replace monkeys now. Justify your decision.
