In 1997, an American company got patent rights on Basmati rice through the US Patent and Trademark Office, for a variety developed by crossing Indian Basmati with semi-dwarf varieties. Which feature of this patent posed the most direct threat to other people, including Indian traders, who sell Basmati rice?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 37 of 80
In 1997, an American company got patent rights on Basmati rice through the US Patent and Trademark Office, for a…
(A) The patent covered the semi-dwarf parent varieties, so breeders elsewhere could no longer use semi-dwarf rice in their crosses.
- Correct answer
(B) The protection reached rice that was functionally equivalent to the patented variety, not just the company's own seeds.
(C) The patent was limited to the company's own seeds, so it could stop only people who copied those exact seeds.
(D) The patent required Indian farmers to pay the company for every Basmati crop they grew in India.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: NCERT notes that the patent "extends to functional equivalents". Because of this, other people selling Basmati rice could be restricted by the patent, even if they had never used the company's seeds. That is what made it a threat to Basmati traders in general.
- (A) is wrong. The patent was claimed on the "new" Basmati variety, not on the semi-dwarf varieties used to breed it.
- (C) is the opposite of the problem. Had the patent covered only the company's own seeds, other sellers would not have been at risk; the functional-equivalents clause reached further.
- (D) is wrong. The patent allowed the company to sell its variety in the US and abroad; NCERT says nothing about charging Indian farmers for growing their own varieties.
