(a)
F=r2GMEMM=(3.84×108)26.67×10−11×6.0×1024×7.35×1022=1.99×1020 N
Each body pulls the other with 1.99×1020 N, so the student is wrong. The two forces are an action–reaction pair (Newton's third law): equal in size and opposite in direction, whatever the masses. The formula itself shows this, since it contains the product MEMM and is the same for both bodies.
(b) Equal forces on unequal masses give unequal accelerations, a=F/M:
aMoonaEarth=F/MMF/ME=MEMM=6.0×10247.35×1022=81.61
aEarth=MEF=6.0×10241.99×1020=3.3×10−5 m s−2
The accelerations of the Earth and the Moon are in the ratio 1:81.6, and the Earth's is 3.3×10−5 m s−2. What the student noticed (the Moon's motion is affected far more) is due to this difference in acceleration, not to any difference in the forces.