Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 64 of 80
An asteroid on a collision course.
Question 645 marksHard
An asteroid on a collision course. An asteroid of mass 1.0×106kg is momentarily at rest relative to the Earth at a distance of 3RE from the Earth's centre. It then falls straight towards the Earth. Ignore the atmosphere, the Earth's rotation and the pull of all other bodies. Take g=9.8m s−2 at the surface and RE=6.4×106m, and use GME=gRE2.
(i) With what speed does the asteroid strike the Earth's surface?
(ii) What is its kinetic energy on impact?
(iii) A student uses v=2gh with h=2RE. What answer does this give, and why is it wrong?
(iv) With what speed would the asteroid strike the Earth if it had started from rest very far away (at "infinity")?
(v) Explain why no body that falls freely towards the Earth, starting from any point at or beyond 3RE, can strike the surface (with no air) at less than about 9km s−1.
(i) Only gravity does work, so mechanical energy is conserved between r=3RE (at rest) and r=RE:
She gets 15.8km s−1, which is too large by a factor 3. This is wrong because v2=2gh assumes the acceleration is g all the way down. In fact the pull at 3RE is only g/9, rising to g only at the surface. The true work done by gravity, 32mgRE, is one third of the student's 2mgRE, so her v2 is 3 times too large.
(iv) Starting from rest at infinity (potential energy zero):
It would strike at 11.2km s−1, the escape speed. This is no accident: the fall from infinity is the escape journey run backwards.
(v) On arrival, 21v2=21u2+GME(RE1−r01), where u is the speed at the starting distance r0. Both terms on the right can only grow if the body starts farther away (1/r0 smaller) or already moving (u>0). The smallest arrival speed from r0≥3RE is therefore the case just worked out, rest at exactly 3RE, which gives 9.14km s−1. So no such body can strike the surface at less than 9.14km s−1; every other one arrives faster, up to 11.2km s−1 or more. Gravity alone makes such impacts extremely violent.