A 5 kg packet hangs from a spring balance fixed to the ceiling of a lift. At a certain instant the balance reads 60 N. Take . Which statement about the lift at that instant is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 45 of 80
A 5 kg packet hangs from a spring balance fixed to the ceiling of a lift.
- Correct answer
(A) Its acceleration is upward; it may be moving up and speeding up, or moving down and slowing down.
(B) Its acceleration is upward, so it must be moving upward.
(C) Its acceleration is downward; it may be moving down and speeding up.
(D) Its acceleration is upward.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Work in the ground frame. The balance reading is the tension in its spring, which acts upward on the packet; the weight acts downward. Taking upward as positive, Newton's second law for the packet gives
The acceleration is upward. Newton's second law tells us the acceleration, not the velocity. An upward acceleration is produced both when the lift moves up with increasing speed and when it moves down with decreasing speed (for example, just before stopping at a lower floor). The reading alone cannot tell these apart.
(B) is wrong: the direction of acceleration does not fix the direction of velocity; a lift slowing down on its way down also has an upward acceleration.
(C) is wrong: a reading greater than the weight means the net force, and so the acceleration, is upward.
(D) is wrong: it divides the whole reading by the mass, , ignoring the weight; the net force is only .
