(a) While the bullet is in the barrel, the expanding gases (through the rifle) push the bullet forward, and by Newton's third law the bullet (through the gases) pushes the rifle backward with an equal force for the same time. The two impulses are equal and opposite, so the momenta given to rifle and bullet are equal and opposite. The system was at rest, so its total momentum stays zero:
mbvb+Mvr=0⇒vr=−Mmbvb=−50.030×300=−1.8 m s−1
The rifle recoils at 1.8 m s−1, opposite to the bullet. The bullet's momentum is 0.030×300=9 kg m s−1 forward and the rifle's is 9 kg m s−1 backward.
(b) The shoulder must remove the rifle's momentum of 9 kg m s−1 in 0.05 s:
Favg=ΔtΔp=0.055×1.8=180 N
directed forward (opposite to the recoil).
(c) If the rifle is held a little away, it first picks up the full recoil speed of 1.8 m s−1 on its own and then strikes the shoulder, which has to stop it in a very short time, so the impulsive force is large and painful. Held firmly, the rifle and the marksman's body recoil together as one much heavier system, so the recoil speed is much smaller, and the shoulder pushes on the rifle throughout the firing instead of being struck by it.
(d) Held firmly, the marksman and rifle move together as one body of mass 70+5=75 kg. On frictionless ice there is no horizontal external force, so the total momentum stays zero, and the marksman and rifle must carry the backward momentum of 9 kg m s−1 that balances the bullet's:
V=750.030×300=759=0.12 m s−1
backward. This is fifteen times smaller than the free rifle's recoil of 1.8 m s−1, which shows why holding the rifle firmly makes the recoil gentle.