Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: The claimed efficiency and the Carnot limit are
η=400100=25%,ηCarnot=1−400300=25%
So the engine claims to reach the limit exactly. Carnot's theorem says no engine between two reservoirs can be more efficient than a reversible (Carnot) engine; reaching the limit requires the engine itself to be reversible. Friction (a dissipative effect) and heat leaking across a finite temperature difference are exactly the causes of irreversibility named in the text. Such an engine wastes some of the energy that a reversible engine would turn into work, so its efficiency must be strictly less than 25%.
The heat leak alone settles it. Suppose a part q of the 400 J leaks straight through the walls from the hot side to the cold side; that part does no work at all. Even if the remaining 400−q were used by a perfect cyclic mechanism at the full 25%, the work would be
W≤0.25(400−q)<100 Jfor any q>0
so W/Q1<25%, and friction lowers it further. The claim cannot be accepted.
(A) is wrong: the test is not "below 100%" but "below the Carnot value for these two temperatures", which here is only 25%.
(C) is wrong: the 300 J is rejected to the surroundings at 300 K; energy is conserved, and the objection comes from the second law, not the first.
(D) is wrong: equality is allowed only for a reversible engine; an engine with friction and heat leaks cannot reach it.