In a laboratory, two students take identical samples of a gas from the same initial state to the same final state . One heats the gas first and then lets it expand; the other lets it expand first and then heats it. Their records of the heat supplied and the work done by the gas differ. For which quantities must the two students get the same values?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 7 of 80
In a laboratory, two students take identical samples of a gas from the same initial state i to the same final state f .
(A) Only the heat supplied and the work done
(B) The heat supplied , the work done and the change in internal energy
(C) Only the change in internal energy and the work done
- Correct answer
(D) The changes in internal energy, pressure, volume and temperature, but not or
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Pressure, volume, temperature and internal energy are state variables: each has a definite value in a given equilibrium state, whatever history brought the gas there. Since both students start at state and finish at state , the changes , , and are the same for both routes.
Heat and work are not state variables. They are energy transferred during a process, and their values depend on the path. On a – diagram the work done is the area under the path, and the two routes enclose different areas. Only their difference is fixed:
(A) is wrong: and are exactly the quantities that depend on the route, as the students' records show.
(B) is wrong: is the same, but and are not.
(C) is wrong: if and were both fixed, would be fixed too, contradicting the different heat records.
