A gas expands quasi-statically and isothermally in a cylinder whose piston rubs against the walls with friction. Explain why this expansion is irreversible, although the same expansion with a frictionless piston would be reversible.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 78 of 80
A gas expands quasi-statically and isothermally in a cylinder whose piston rubs against the walls with friction.
With a frictionless piston, every step of the slow isothermal expansion can be undone exactly: compressing the gas back along the same isotherm returns to the surroundings exactly the work and heat they gave, so both the gas and the surroundings return to their original states. Friction always opposes the motion, whichever way the piston moves. During the expansion, part of the gas's work is spent against friction and appears as heat; during the reverse compression, extra work must again be done against friction, and that too appears as heat. Instead of cancelling, the two frictional losses add up, so after the round trip the surroundings have given up work and received heat, which cannot be turned completely back into work. Friction is a dissipative effect, and dissipative effects make a process irreversible even when it is quasi-static.
