Two identical cylinders contain identical samples of a gas in the same initial state. In cylinder 1 the piston is locked and the gas is heated by a flame until its internal energy has increased by . Cylinder 2 is thermally insulated, and its piston is pushed in until the internal energy of its gas has also increased by .
(a) For each cylinder, state the heat supplied to the gas and the work done on the gas.
(b) A student says the gas in cylinder 1 "now contains more heat" while the gas in cylinder 2 "contains more work". Explain why both statements are meaningless.
(c) If, at the end, the two gases happen to be at the same pressure, volume and temperature, can anyone tell, by examining the gases, how each one got there? Explain.
