(a) Claimed efficiency and the Carnot limit:
ηclaim=1500600=40%,ηCarnot=1−600400=33.3%
The claim exceeds the Carnot efficiency, which Carnot's theorem says no engine between these temperatures can do. Part (c) shows why.
(b) A reversible Carnot cycle run backwards exchanges the same quantities with the reservoirs, with every arrow reversed, and still obeys Q1/Q2=T1/T2. To deliver Q1=1500 J to the source:
Q2=Q1T1T2=1500×600400=1000 J (taken from the sink),W=Q1−Q2=500 J
(c) Per cycle of the pair:
- Source: gives 1500 J to the engine and receives 1500 J from the refrigerator; net change zero.
- Sink: receives 1500−600=900 J from the engine and gives 1000 J to the refrigerator; net 100 J taken from the sink.
- Work: the engine delivers 600 J, the refrigerator uses 500 J; net 100 J delivered.
The only result of the combined device would be taking 100 J of heat from a single reservoir (the sink) and converting it entirely into work. This violates the Kelvin–Planck statement of the second law. Energy is conserved, so the first law is not the objection; the claim is impossible because of the second law. Any engine claiming more than 33.3% here can be exposed in the same way.