An inventor claims that her engine, working between a hot reservoir at and a cold reservoir at , delivers of work for every of heat it takes from the hot reservoir. What is the correct verdict?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 17 of 80
An inventor claims that her engine, working between a hot reservoir at 500 K and a cold reservoir at 300 K , delivers…
- Correct answer
(A) Impossible: the claimed efficiency, , exceeds the maximum possible efficiency of between these temperatures.
(B) Possible: the claimed efficiency is well below , and energy is conserved since is rejected.
(C) Possible: the maximum efficiency between these temperatures is , which is above .
(D) Impossible: the engine would reject , which is more than the work it delivers, so the first law is violated.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: The claimed efficiency is
By Carnot's theorem, no engine working between two given temperatures can be more efficient than a Carnot engine working between them:
Since , the claim is impossible. If such an engine existed, coupling it to a reversible engine run backwards would give a device that turns heat from one reservoir entirely into work, against the second law.
(B) is wrong: being consistent with energy conservation (the first law) is not enough; the second law requires at least of the heat taken in () to be rejected, and this engine rejects only .
(C) is wrong: the formula divides by the cold temperature; the Carnot efficiency is .
(D) is wrong: rejecting 1100 J while doing 900 J of work is perfectly consistent with the first law (); the claim fails on the second law, not the first.
