A student plots the isotherms of of a gas at and at on the same – graph, and her two curves cross at one point.
Why must her graph be wrong?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 56 of 80
A student plots the isotherms of of a gas at and at on the same – graph, and her two curves cross at one point.
Why must her graph be wrong?
(A) At the crossing, one pair of values would belong to two different temperatures, but the equation of state of a fixed amount of gas gives a single temperature for each .
(B) Isotherms are parallel straight lines on a – graph, so two of them can never meet.
(C) At the crossing, heat would flow from the curve to the curve, which the zeroth law forbids.
(D) Isotherms of an ideal gas cannot cross, but those of a real gas can, so she must have used ideal-gas values for a real gas.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: An isotherm is the set of all equilibrium states of the sample that have one temperature. The state of a fixed amount of gas in equilibrium is fixed by two variables, and the equation of state then gives the third; for an ideal gas
A crossing point would be a single state with two temperatures, and at once, which is impossible because temperature is a single-valued state variable. For an ideal gas the isotherms are the hyperbolas ; a larger simply gives a curve lying everywhere farther from the axes.
(B) is wrong: isotherms of an ideal gas are rectangular hyperbolas (), not straight lines; the reason they do not meet is not their shape.
(C) is wrong: points on a graph are states of one sample, not two bodies in contact; nothing flows between curves, and the zeroth law is about thermal equilibrium of separate systems.
(D) is wrong: any gas in equilibrium has an equation of state giving one temperature for each , so the isotherms of a real gas cannot cross either.