Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: First check the engine alone: its efficiency is 250/900=27.8%, below the Carnot value 1−300/450=33.3%, so it is a perfectly possible engine.
Now add up one cycle of the combination:
- Source: gives 900 J to the engine and receives 650 J from the refrigerator; net 250 J taken from the source.
- Sink: receives 650 J from the engine and gives 650 J to the refrigerator; net change zero.
- Work: 250 J delivered by the engine; the refrigerator needs none.
The sole result would be 250 J of heat taken from a single reservoir and converted completely into work. That is exactly what the Kelvin–Planck statement forbids. So if the Clausius statement could be broken, the Kelvin–Planck statement could be broken too: the two statements are equivalent forms of the second law, and the claimed refrigerator is impossible.
(B) is wrong: the 250 J of work is balanced by 250 J of heat taken from the source, so energy is conserved; the objection comes from the second law.
(C) is wrong: the combination also includes the engine; its net effect is not a heat transfer but the complete conversion of heat into work, which is a Kelvin–Planck violation.
(D) is wrong: 650 J of the 900 J is returned to the source, so only the net 250 J is converted.