Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 51 of 80

An ordinary engine works between a source at 450 K and a sink at 300 K .

Question 511 markMCQHard

An ordinary engine works between a source at 450 K450\ \text{K} and a sink at 300 K300\ \text{K}. In each cycle it takes 900 J900\ \text{J} from the source, does 250 J250\ \text{J} of work and gives 650 J650\ \text{J} to the sink. Someone claims to have built a "perfect refrigerator" which, with no work done on it, takes 650 J650\ \text{J} from the sink and delivers it to the source in each cycle. The two devices are run together.

What would the combination achieve, and what does this show?

Select your answer
  • (A) It would take a net 250 J250\ \text{J} from the source alone and turn all of it into work, leaving the sink unchanged; so a device that violated the Clausius statement would also violate the Kelvin–Planck statement.

    Correct answer
  • (B) It would deliver 250 J250\ \text{J} of work while taking no net heat from either reservoir, so it would violate the first law.

  • (C) It would only move 650 J650\ \text{J} from the sink to the source, so it violates the Clausius statement again and says nothing about the Kelvin–Planck statement.

  • (D) It would take 900 J900\ \text{J} from the source and turn all of it into work, so it would violate the Kelvin–Planck statement.