Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 60 of 80
Two statements are given below. One is labelled Assertion
Question 601 markMCQHard
Two statements are given below. One is labelled Assertion (A) and the other is labelled Reason (R). Read the statements carefully and choose the option that correctly describes statements A and R.
Assertion (A): A semi-elliptical arch and a parabolic arch (vertical axis) have the same span and the same height. At every point of the span other than the two ends and the centre, the semi-elliptical arch is higher than the parabolic arch.
Reason (R): The two arches pass through the same three points: the two ends of the span and the top.
Select your answer
(A) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, and Reason (R) is the correct explanation of Assertion (A).
(B) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, but Reason (R) is not the correct explanation of Assertion (A).
Correct answer
(C) Assertion (A) is true, but Reason (R) is false.
(D) Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
Let the span be 2p and the height h, with the centre of the base at x=0.
Assertion (A) is true. Semi-ellipse: p2x2+h2y2=1 gives the height h1−p2x2. Parabola: with its vertex (the top) at the origin it is x2=−4ay through (p,−h), so at x the arch is p2hx2 below the top, and its height above the base is h(1−p2x2). Put s=1−p2x2; for 0<∣x∣<p we have 0<s<1, and then
s>s(since s(1−s)>0)
So hs>hs: the elliptical arch is higher. At the centre (s=1) and at the ends (s=0) the heights are equal.
Reason (R) is true. Both arches have height 0 at x=±p (the ends of the span) and height h at x=0 (the top), since they share the span and the height.
R does not explain A. Many different curves pass through the same three points; sharing them says nothing about which arch is higher between them. A needs the comparison s>s.
Why the other options are wrong
(A) R is true but is not the reason for A: three shared points cannot decide which arch is higher at the other points.
(C) R is true: both arches have height 0 at the two ends and height h at the top.