Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Step 1: ignore the refusal. With 5 members, at least 2 men and at least 2 women, the make-up is 3 men + 2 women or 2 men + 3 women.
6C3×5C2+6C2×5C3=20×10+15×10=350
Step 2: count the committees in Step 1 that contain both Xavier and Yasmin. They must still obey the gender rule.
- 3 men + 2 women: Xavier and 2 of the other 5 men, Yasmin and 1 of the other 4 women: 5C2×4C1=10×4=40.
- 2 men + 3 women: Xavier and 1 of the other 5 men, Yasmin and 2 of the other 4 women: 5C1×4C2=5×6=30.
So 70 committees must be removed.
350−70=280
Why the other options are wrong
- (B) 350 obeys the gender rule but ignores the refusal. It still contains the 70 committees with both Xavier and Yasmin.
- (C) 70 is the number of committees that contain both Xavier and Yasmin, which are exactly the committees that are not allowed.
- (D) 350−9C3=350−84=266 removes every way of adding 3 people to Xavier and Yasmin. Some of these, such as Xavier, Yasmin and 3 more men (4 men, 1 woman), were never among the 350, so too many are removed.