Step 3: check both. For k=2 the data 2,4,6,8,10 have mean 6 and ∑(xi−6)2=16+4+0+4+16=40, so σ2=8. For k=12 the data 4,6,8,10,12 have mean 8 and the same squared deviations, so σ2=8. Both values are correct.
Why the other options are wrong
(A) "k=12 only" drops the root k=2. A new value below the data can spread it just as much as one above it, and k=2 gives variance 8 as shown.
(C) 7±15 divides the sum of squared deviations by 4 instead of 5: it solves ∑(xi−xˉ)2=32, that is k2−14k+34=0. The variance for these values is 532, not 8.
(D) 7±25 uses 7, the mean of the four known readings, as if it were the mean of all five: 59+1+1+9+(k−7)2=8. But k changes the mean; for these values the true variance is 536, not 8.