Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 27 of 80
A laboratory tests two sensors by taking four readings with each (in suitable units).
Question 272 marksMedium
A laboratory tests two sensors by taking four readings with each (in suitable units).
Sensor P: 2, 2, 8, 8
Sensor Q: 0, 4, 6, 10
(i) Show that the two sets of readings have the same mean and the same mean deviation about the mean.
(ii) Find the standard deviation of each set (correct to two decimal places where needed), and state which set is more spread out according to the standard deviation.
(i) Both sets add up to 20, so both means are 420=5.
Reading of P
2
2
8
8
∣xi−5∣
3
3
3
3
Reading of Q
0
4
6
10
∣xi−5∣
5
1
1
5
M.D. of P=43+3+3+3=3,M.D. of Q=45+1+1+5=3
So the means are equal and the mean deviations about the mean are equal. (1 mark)
By the standard deviation, Q is more spread out. The mean deviation cannot separate the two sets, because it gives the deviations 5, 1, 1, 5 the same total as 3, 3, 3, 3. Squaring gives more weight to the large deviations, so the SD picks up that Q's readings 0 and 10 lie farther from the mean. So two sets can have the same mean deviation but different standard deviations. (1 mark)